MLB The Show 23

Complete: $22
Sealed: $38
Sales: 20+in 90 days

Variants

Region

Any NTSC Asia

Edition

Standard $19–$2520+ sales The Captain EditionOther $17–$253 sales

Complete $19–$2520+ sales Sealed $381 sale Loose $24–$262 sales Incomplete —no sales Graded CIB —no sales Graded —no sales

Market value

$19–$25 typical$21.7020+ sales in 90 days

$19 $25

Liquidity 85 of 100

around 20 sold in 90 days · sells in about 2 days

High confidence

20+ sales, newest Oct 31

Sales history

13 recorded complete sales of MLB The Show 23, every region, newest first
Sold		Region	Edition	Condition	Price
Oct 31, 2026 sold in 14 days	MLB The Show 23 - Sony Playstation 4 (2023) CIB Complete Oct 31, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$24.99 eBay · Offer accepted asking price shown
Oct 29, 2026 sold in under 1 day	MLB The Show 23 PS4 PlayStation 4 Disc CIB Tested NTSC Oct 29, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	~~$24.99~~ $21 eBay · Offer accepted
Oct 21, 2026 sold in under 1 day	Sony Interactive MLB The Show 23 PS4 2023 E Multiplayer Online NTSC-U/C Oct 21, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$18.50 eBay
Oct 20, 2026 sold in 3 days	Sony MLB The Show 23 Video Game PS4 Excellent Jazz Chisholm Jr Cover Oct 20, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$25 eBay
Oct 16, 2026 sold in under 1 day	PlayStation 4 - MLB The Show 23 - Complete Oct 16, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$21.95 eBay
Oct 14, 2026 sold in 4 days	MLB The Show 23 PS4 PlayStation 4 Disc Case Artwork No Manual Tested NTSC Oct 14, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	~~$24.99~~ $20 eBay · Offer accepted
Oct 11, 2026 sold in 3 days	PlayStation 4 - MLB The Show 23 - Complete Oct 11, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$21.99 eBay
Oct 10, 2026 sold in under 1 day	MLB The Show 23 - Sony PlayStation 4, 2023 PS4 Comes With Code. Oct 10, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	~~$34.95~~ $28.28 eBay · Offer accepted
Oct 6, 2026 sold in under 1 day	MLB The Show 23 - Sony Playstation 4 (2023) Oct 6, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$19.99 eBay
Oct 5, 2026 sold in 3 weeks	MLB The Show 23 (Sony PlayStation 4 PS4, 2023) Oct 5, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$25.99 eBay
Oct 4, 2026 sold in 7 days	MLB The Show 23 (Sony PlayStation 4 Ps4) Oct 4, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$6.67 eBay · Auction
Oct 2, 2026 sold in under 1 day	MLB The Show 23 • Sony PlayStation 4 • Disc & Case • Tested Works Used Oct 2, 2026NTSC · Standard	NTSC	Standard	Complete	$24.99 eBay

Frequently asked

How much is MLB The Show 23 worth on PlayStation 4?

A complete copy sells for about $22. Most go for $19 to $25.

Which editions of MLB The Show 23 exist on PlayStation 4?

The Standard and the The Captain Edition. The price at the top of the page is for standard copies.

Standard $19–$2520+ sales
The Captain Edition $17–$253 sales

How quickly does MLB The Show 23 sell?

Around 2 copies sell per week. The cheapest listings sell within about 2 days.

How is sales data gathered?

We retrieve listing information through eBay alerts and Vinted alerts provided by GrailHound and apply image recognition and text processing to link marketplace listings to games.

Is MLB The Show 23 available on other platforms?

Yes, also available on Xbox One, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X.